Nothing to fear but everything itself?

With the stock market sitting at half the level it did a decade ago, and with new surveys showing carnage in consumer confidence and housing, I’m struck by the saturated language of the national nightmare. (It’s not just the apocalyptic headlines driving us to despair.) This story from the Associated Press today gathers the poetry of the pain — after its lead sentence announcing that American confidence went into “free fall” in February, the relatively short dispatch uses each of the following terms at least twice:

fear (2)homer_thescream
decline (2)
plummet (2)
plunge (2)
collapse (2)
severe (2)
slash (2)
shrinking (2)
battered (2)
suffer (3)
drop (4)
sink/sank (4)
worried (4)
low (6)

Superlative phrases in the story include “massive job cuts,” “driven to their lowest level ever” (consumer expectations) and “the largest drop in its 21-year history” (a national home price index).

Recently a friend sent me an email wondering why President Obama hasn’t done more to talk up confidence as he’s traveled around promoting his economic recovery plan. The answer probably lies most in the calculus of Capitol Hill, and the political pressure apparently needed to pass his legislative agenda. There’s also Obama’s admirable position that he won’t sugarcoat the truth about our troubles the way the administration before him did to such disastrous effect.

But it’s a daunting balancing act with perception at this point. You don’t have to be an economist to sense how the downward spiral of fear could itself become deeply damaging. (If it hasn’t already — as Robert Shiller warned in a recent column, a Great Depression narrative “could easily end up as a self-fulfilling prophecy.”) And Obama’s political opponents increasingly are able to agitate using raw emotional appeal: Last night CNN’s in-house ideologue Lou Dobbs hammered at Obama’s “fear mongering” and accused him of repeatedly talking down the markets and economy. In the New York Times today David Brooks feigns sympathy for the president while suggesting that Team Obama is in way over its head. (“I hope the president succeeds even though he probably won’t!” is the message.)

Many will be watching intently tonight when Obama addresses a joint session of Congress for the first time. The only positive polling in sight shows that he’s still got the thumbs-up on job approval from a decisive majority of the public. It’s a remarkable measure of confidence floating on a tide of ugly numbers — Americans believe Obama will sail us in the right direction, even with no horizon in view.


2 comments so far

  1. jmf on

    Government attempts at a soft landing may not work at all. WPA projects during the Depression didn’t ward off the coming of the Depression, they rebuilt an economy from the bottom up.

    If some expenditures do succeed in easing the recession, the efficient use of dollars will be far from perfect. In ways yet recognizable, viable opportunities for business will emerge, some born of governmental tweaking, some simply born of recessionary times. Not all economic sectors nor all Americans will escape severe alterations to business or life style.

    Obama helping scared citizens to understand these realities is a tall order. I remain convinced that the media reflects public sentiment- it reports us to ourselves. I think soon our fear-and-blame-talk will change to defining-sacrifice-talk. From sacrificed luxury spending to sacrifice in health care, education and, maybe, war. We will be forced into the business of recasting priorities in daily living. Life can be different without being tragic and compensating acts vs. whining about perceived entitlements will go a long way in defining personal happiness.

  2. Peter L. Griffiths on

    The Community Reinvestment Act required United States banks to lend to people who were likely to default particularly if the price of housing fell. This meant that the banks were faced with defaulting debts which they tried to pass on to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac whose insolvency was the main cause of the financial crisis 2007-2009.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: